Probably my favorite! We have bought dozens of bottles of Proof, given gift sets, use it daily. It should be your GO to for Old Fashioneds!
This may be my favorite! I've made my mother in law a few old fashion's from this syrup and shes loves it too.
Finally tried the Black Walnut; why did I wait?? Makes a very smooth and rich tasting old fashioned. My favorite was the Orange, but now not sure! Get it.
Makes a great old fashioned.
Outstanding. Highly recommended.
Very good, love the black walnut syrup in my old fashioned.
The black walnut makes the best old fashioned, I have tried it with several different bourbons, delicious!!!
It is yummy. I am now a bourbon drinker. Our friends love it!
Not my flavor.
A nice Perdomo Madura, a Woodsford Reserve Old Fashioned and football on a beautiful fall afternoon! Love the black Walnut or Maple Bacon syrup with a Luxardo cherry.
Made a Tequila old fashion for guests at Thanksgiving and everyone was so grateful! They loved it and wanted another!
Outstanding Old Fashioned syrup mix. Using Elijah Craig for spirits.
Great product that I enjoy but I unsubscribed from all the marketing emails weeks ago and they keep coming. Enough already, I bought syrup, not a new car.
My go to is the Smoked Old Fashioned with white oak chips, Buffalo Trace Bourbon, and the dark walnut proof syrup. Perfect everytime!
Taste great!! Nice, smooth, and easy to make
Delicious flavor to add to any bourbon or any bourbon infusion.
My favorite of all the Old Fashiond flavors. Perfect balance without being overstated. Delicious cocktails every time !
Perfect drink every time!
Absolutely love the Black Walnut with my favorite bourbon!!
Good stuff love mixing it with other things reminds me of the black walnut candy when I was a kid kid I had the store in Toledo Ohio balk liquor store on sequor start getting it in stock after I told them about it thank you
With a good bourbon, smooth and rounded. Very enjoyable
I love the Pecan Proof Old Fashioned Syrup, so I was very hopeful that I'd like the Black Walnut flavor as much or even more. I guess I really like the nutty flavors, because I think Black Walnut is fantastic, too!
Absolutely fabulous, one of the best old fashions I’ve ever had… Thank you for making a fabulous product my liquor store would also like to thank you as well, I am buying a lot more bourbon because of your proof… LOL
Perfect mix for making an old fashioned. Simple to and not overly sweet. I use 1/2 oz mix with 1oz bourbon and 1oz rye topped with a splash of club soda.
This black walnut proof is so smooth with Woodford Reserve double oaked! Love it. 10/10 reccomend
My favorite drink with this syrup is what I call a Charleston Whiskey. Sagamore Rye, Black Walnut Syrup to taste and one shake of orange bitters.
I love the black walnut flavor! So delicious!
OMG! This syrup with bourbon or rye eclipses our favorite Manhattan by far! Cocktail heaven.
Delicious smoked old fashioned
Excellent quality, beautiful presentation, and cool bottle! Thanks for making my old fashioned a two step process.
I am a fan of a good Old Fashiond, but the addition of the Black Walnut Proof syrup takes it to another level. I have given Proof syrups as gifts, but sometimes the best gift is one you gave to yourself.
I really wanted to LOVE this because I am a massive fan of black walnut. I'm not saying it's not good. It's fine. But the black walnut is very subtle and, in my opinion, doesn't come through enough in cocktails. I plan to buy from Proof again, but I'll probably go with a different flavor profile for the mixers that I try from them in the future.
I’ve got my whole family and many friends hooked on Proof. Love your product!
Professional Old Fashion at home
The Proof syrup allows me to whip up a sactisfactory Old Fashion in no time. I ordered the walnut syrup. I found it a bit overly sweet, and the flavor is not as "walnut-ty" as adding Negroni walnut liqueur.
I love all the proof flavors, black walnut and ginger are both my favorites
I ordered 3 different ones and this was my favorite. Awesome and easy to use.
The black walnut proof is the best yet, well at least until the pumpkin is back, but the black walnut is a standard and is delecious!
Black walnut proof syrup and Blanton’s- awesome Old Fashioned …perfect match with a nice cigar
Perfect taste to my evening.
I love all the Proof syrups but the Black Walnut is my favorite!! My friends are now addicted as well!
Thank you ….. Diana
The Black Walnut Proof Syrup is even better than I imagined. I can make an awesome Old Fashioned in seconds!
Prefer the Black Walnut to Traditional, which is good as well. Would take a photo but somehow my old fashioned glass is empty.
Love the experience
I have been trying for months to make a great walnut old fashioned and have consistently missed the mark. With Proof, it's fool proof. Smooth and delicious!
Too many choices. But love the new black walnut w bourbon or rye and a lemon twist instead of an orange twist.
Not quite sure all the taste I expected is there..but still beats all the work of making an old fashioned from scratch!
Black Walnut makes The best old fashion! I also enjoy the Pecan
Liked it better than Traditional, which I also liked
This drink is delicious! A little smoother than the original syrup and a nice variation of the old fashioned.
The black walnut is very good. Gives the old fashion a totally different flavor gives the bourbon more depth. Awesome
Very nice flavor, takes edge off strong whiskey but keeps it real. Recommend rye whiskey with this flavor as the walnut flavor combines with rye to create a smooth drink with a little heat.
My sister enjoyed her first drink with Proof syrup. I knew she would!
Was skeptical when ordering but was pleasantly surprised. Will be ordering more.
So. Damn. Good.
Black Walnut makes the Best Old Fashioned and great with rum and coke.
All my normal glasses were in the wash, but this made an awesome Manhattan nevertheless! The sweet nutty combo was a great twist.
This stuff is the best tasting mixer there is for an all in one, however, at $35 a bottle, that is about the cost of a medium quality bourbon, like Bulliet. Therefore, the mixer should never cost this much. So for me, this was a one time purchase until the price is reasonable, about $14-15 a bottle.
Outstanding!!! Mix and pour!!
Very good taste, can taste the hint of black walnut, is now a go to for me.
Pendleton 1910 and black walnut proof syrup with a dash of my smoked whiskey and a smoked cherry is my favorite old fashioned to date!
It was a great old fashioned with just the right amount taste of walnut. My godson, Zach, who is an Old Fashioned expert loved it.
Definitely was very good in the drink. I was not able to taste any Walnut flavor
The best old fashion this girl has ever had. Four and black walnut proof
Use a good bourbon and you can’t go wrong!
Love the Proof Black Walnut. Easy to make a great old fashioned, easy to drink. Goes great with a Woodford bourbon barrel soaked cherry!
Being from New Orleans I love Old Fashions. Proof syrup makes the experience so easy, and the black walnut adds a different twist to a classic cocktail
Still makes a great Old Fashioned, but doesn’t really have a walnut taste.
Love the syrup- love the company. He's loving the bourbon, walnut syrup and bada bing cherry concoction he's drinking! Thanks for making such a delicious product.
The syrup is amazing and we love it. Unfortunately we are trying to order more and the site is telling me that you don’t deliver to Alaska, so I can’t place another order. Would love to purchase several more bottles
The Black walnut is awesome. Goes great with bourbon straight!
Absolutely love this stuff. Always drink neat but on the occasion I don't this stuff is a home run. Makes an good bourbon a 10/10.
I am a big fan of the traditional syrup and was so excited to try the black walnut. Unfortunately, it just doesn’t have much flavor. It’s fine to use to add a touch of sweet, but any black walnut taste (and I still am not sure it’s there) is quickly overpowered by the alcohol.
While I love the Original Proof, the Black Walnut left me wanting a more intense walnut flavor and didn’t improve my bourbon cocktail
I really love the sweet, nutty and slightly bitter flavor of this Proof Black Walnut. I’ve been mixing up delicious cocktails with some good rye and sweet vermouth for classy evenings at home. Proof syrups taste great and have enhanced my mixed drink game.
We made a proof libre with the black walnut and it was great. We also made a black walnut old fashion which came out good.
Our favorite new drink the “Old Fashioned Fruitcake”. 1 1/2 oz. Bourbon, 1/2 oz. Proof Black Walnut, 1/2 oz. Grand Marnier, orange wedge and a Filthy Red Cherry.
Love the pecan, black walnut, traditional a lot and would purchase again. The pomegranate tastes like bad cough syrup, disappointing because that was the one I was looking forward to trying
Proof has the best cocktail syrup around. Please make more. I will be waiting to try all your new flavors. Thanks
Such an easy way to have a delicious Old Fashion. The only problem is, that it's so good you can't have just one.
We used Proof Syrup with Mr. Black and it is great! My wife also likes it with her Bourbon!
Amazing flavor! Traditional proof and Elijah Craig bourbon made a great old fashioned.
So black walnut is my definitely a contender for traditional. The taste is refined and not as robust as traditional but it works REALLY well with an overproofed rye such as EH Taylor. Get your hands on this one and bring out more flavors!
Tried the Traditional and loved it. Ordered another Traditional and the Black Walnut and found I like the Black Walnut even more. Great products!!!
Jameson cold brew whiskey and black walnut Proof- perfect combo and my favorite flavor by far !!
Maple Bacon Crown Royal Manhattan for Super Bowl
So delicious!! Best, easiest Old Fashion. Highly recommend!!
My hubby loves the Black Walnut the best!
This ad was haunting me on Facebook so I finally gave in and ordered. I’m so glad I did because Proof makes the best old fashioned ever!! I will be ordering more and trying all the flavors! And I’ll be giving bottles as gifts to my favorite people. Thanks!!
I order two bottles as Christmas gifts. On Christmas Eve my friends and I enjoyed a couple of delicious Old Fashioned cocktails and they were delicious. I had also bought them some embossed ice cube makers but we didn't have time to freeze those ice balls but they had large square ice cubes which we used and they made the drink chilled and melted so slowly that the taste never got diluted. I love Proof Syrup and will definitely be ordering more in the future.
This is the best syrup I've ever had.
The Black Walnut Proof syrup is so delicious! We've been making Old Fashioneds regularly now that we have this syrup. Can't wait to try some of your other syrups... I've got my eyes on that Bees Knees blend!
It took them almost a month to simply ship the syrup. After I contacted them several times I finally heard back and they said they were experiencing delays. The should have let me know about delays at the time of my order. I ordered this item as a Christmas present well before and it arrived quite a while after Christmas. I won't order from this company again because of this.
Expected more but just ok.