The usual mistake with a DIY Old Fashioned kit is filling the box with things that look like a bar and leaving out the things that make a drink. A muddler, a strainer and a cocktail book photograph well, and then sit in a drawer. A good kit is short: whiskey, a sweetener that already has the bitters in it, proper ice, a peeler and a recipe. Start with a bottle of Proof Traditional syrup and the rest of the box is easy to fill. Here is what to put in, what to leave out and how to pack it.

What Makes a Great Old Fashioned Kit

An Old Fashioned has three working parts: whiskey, sweetener and bitters, plus ice and a peel. Most gift kits handle the whiskey and the glassware and then hand the recipient a bag of sugar cubes and a bottle of bitters, which is the part most likely to go wrong at home.

The sweetener slot is what makes the drink. Get it right and almost any decent whiskey turns into a good Old Fashioned. Get it wrong and a very nice bottle turns into something gritty and unbalanced. So build the kit around the syrup, and choose everything else to support it. The test for every other item is simple: will they use it the first night.

What to Put in the Box

  • One or two bottles of Old Fashioned syrup. This is the center of the kit. Traditional is the safe first pick; add a second flavor if you know their taste.
  • A bottle of whiskey. Bourbon for a rounder, sweeter drink or rye for a drier one. A solid mid-shelf bottle is the right call. Save the rare stuff for drinking neat.
  • A large-cube ice mold. Silicone, two-inch cubes. This is the item people do not buy for themselves and then use every week.
  • A peeler. A plain Y-peeler makes better orange twists than a knife. Tuck in an orange or two if you are handing the kit over in person.
  • A bar spoon. Long, with a twisted shaft. Optional but useful.
  • A jar of cocktail cherries. For people who like one in the glass. Dark, syrup-packed cherries, not the neon ones.
  • One or two rocks glasses. Heavy-bottomed and plain.
  • A recipe card. Handwritten is better. The recipe below fits on an index card.

Leave out the muddler, the shaker and the strainer. None of them are needed for this drink.

The Recipe Card to Include

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Add the whiskey and syrup to a rocks glass.
  2. Add one large ice cube.
  3. Stir for 20 to 30 seconds, until the glass feels cold.
  4. Squeeze the orange peel over the drink, skin side down, and drop it in.

That is the whole drink. One bottle of syrup makes about 32 cocktails, which works out to roughly $1.09 per cocktail on the syrup side. It is worth writing "makes about 32" on the card so they know the gift lasts well past the holidays.

Why the Sweetener Matters

Proof syrups are made in small batches with raw cane sugar, which gives the drink more body and a rounder finish than white sugar. The aromatic bitters are cooked into the syrup, so the recipient does not need a separate bottle of bitters, a sugar cube or a muddler. That is what lets the kit stay small. It also means the first drink they make from your box tastes like the tenth one will, which is not usually how a first Old Fashioned goes.

If you are not sure which flavor suits them, our guide to which Proof syrup flavor to buy first sorts it out by what they already drink.

Kit Variations by Recipient

Same box, different syrup. Pick the one that matches the person.

The Classic Kit

In the box

Best for: someone new to making cocktails at home, or anyone whose taste you do not know well.

The Rye Drinker's Kit

In the box

Best for: the person who orders Manhattans and likes a drier, nuttier drink.

The Brunch Kit

In the box

Best for: hosts and weekend cooks. Maple Bacon is not vegan, so check before you wrap it.

The Citrus Kit

In the box

Best for: people who like a brighter, softer Old Fashioned.

The Sampler Kit

In the box

Best for: someone with a stocked whiskey shelf already, where another bottle would be one too many.

Tips for Putting It Together

Pack around the glass

Syrup and whiskey bottles are heavy. Stand them upright, wrap each in tissue or a tea towel, and fill the gaps with crinkle paper so nothing knocks together. Put the glasses in last, with the recipe card on top.

Choose the box for reuse

A wooden crate, a lidded basket or a plain sturdy gift box all work. The recipient should be able to keep the kit together on a shelf afterward.

Match the whiskey to the syrup

Bourbon suits Traditional and Orange. Rye stands up well to Black Walnut. If you want more than a rule of thumb, see bourbon vs. rye in cocktails.

Shipping it or short on time

If the kit has to travel, skip the fresh oranges and the glassware. If you are out of time, a Proof gift card lets them pick their own flavors, and the subscription box keeps the syrup coming after the first bottle runs out.

Start With the Syrup

A good DIY Old Fashioned kit is a short list done well: the whiskey, the syrup, the ice, the peel and a card that says how. Choose the syrup first and the rest follows. All four in-stock flavors are in the Old Fashioned syrup collection.

Link to share

Use this link to share the article with a friend.