The common mistake with these two drinks is treating them as the same thing in different glasses. They share a base spirit and a dash of bitters, and that is about where it ends. An Old Fashioned is whiskey sweetened with sugar; a Manhattan is whiskey sweetened with vermouth. Once you see that, the old fashioned vs manhattan question mostly answers itself. For the Old Fashioned side, a bottle of Proof Traditional syrup covers the sugar and the bitters in one pour. The Manhattan side takes a little more explaining, so here it is.

What Makes a Great Old Fashioned or Manhattan

Both drinks have three working parts: a spirit, a sweetener and bitters. The spirit gets all the attention, but the sweetener slot is what decides which drink you are holding.

In an Old Fashioned, that slot is filled by sugar. Traditionally a cube muddled with bitters and a splash of water, more reliably a syrup. The sugar adds weight and rounds off the heat, and otherwise stays out of the way. The drink tastes like the whiskey you chose, slightly softened.

In a Manhattan, the slot is filled by sweet vermouth, a fortified wine flavored with herbs and spices. Vermouth brings sweetness, but also wine, bitterness and a long herbal finish. The drink tastes like whiskey and something else in conversation. Neither is better. They are different jobs.

Old Fashioned vs. Manhattan at a Glance

  • Sweetener: sugar or syrup in an Old Fashioned; sweet vermouth in a Manhattan.
  • Whiskey: bourbon is the usual Old Fashioned pick; rye is the classic Manhattan choice. Either drink works with either.
  • Glass and ice: an Old Fashioned is served in a rocks glass over ice. A Manhattan is stirred with ice, then strained into a chilled stemmed glass with no ice.
  • Garnish: an orange peel for the Old Fashioned; a cherry for the Manhattan.
  • Character: the Old Fashioned is spirit-forward and changes slowly as the ice melts. The Manhattan is richer and more aromatic, and tastes the same from first sip to last.

The Old Fashioned is the older idea. Spirit, sugar, water and bitters is the original early-1800s definition of a cocktail. The Manhattan arrived later in the same century, in New York, once vermouth had become a regular behind American bars.

Old Fashioned Recipe

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Add the whiskey and syrup to a rocks glass.
  2. Add one large ice cube.
  3. Stir for 20 to 30 seconds, until the glass is cold to the touch.
  4. Express the orange peel over the drink, run it around the rim and drop it in.

Manhattan Recipe

The from-scratch build is 2 oz rye, 1 oz sweet vermouth and 2 dashes of aromatic bitters. The shorter route uses the Proof Manhattan syrup, a limited release that is available for pre-order now and ships early December. It is made with Italian sweet vermouth and aromatic bitters, so you add whiskey and a cherry.

Ingredients

  • 2 oz rye or bourbon
  • 1 oz Proof Manhattan syrup (pre-order, ships early December)
  • Ice for stirring
  • Cocktail cherry

Instructions

  1. Chill a coupe or other stemmed glass in the freezer.
  2. Add the whiskey and syrup to a mixing glass and fill it with ice.
  3. Stir for about 30 seconds.
  4. Strain into the chilled glass and garnish with a cherry.

There is a longer write-up of this build in our Manhattan recipe post.

Why the Sweetener Matters

Because the sweetener defines each drink, it is also where each one usually goes wrong. An Old Fashioned made with a half-dissolved sugar cube is gritty at the bottom and thin at the top. A Manhattan made with vermouth that has sat open on a shelf for months tastes flat and a little sour, since vermouth is wine and behaves like it.

Proof syrups are made in small batches with raw cane sugar, which gives the drink more body and a rounder finish than white sugar and water. The aromatic bitters are cooked in, so an Old Fashioned comes down to whiskey, syrup, ice and a peel. The measuring is done once, at the kettle, instead of every time at the counter.

Variations

Once the sweetener slot makes sense, variations are just a matter of what you put in it.

Black Walnut Old Fashioned

Ingredients

Best for: Manhattan drinkers who want an Old Fashioned. The nutty, slightly bitter note gets closest to that vermouth depth.

Orange Old Fashioned

Ingredients

Best for: anyone who likes the citrus side of the drink and a softer, brighter finish.

Maple Bacon Old Fashioned

Ingredients

Best for: cold nights and brunch. It is smoky and savory, and it is not vegan.

Black Walnut Manhattan

Ingredients

Best for: rye drinkers after dinner. Stir and strain it like the Manhattan above.

Technique Tips for Both Drinks

Stir, never shake

Both drinks are all spirit and sweetener, with no juice. Stirring chills them and keeps them clear and heavy. Shaking adds air and ice chips, which make either one cloudy and thin.

Pick the whiskey for the drink

Bourbon makes both drinks sweeter and rounder; rye makes them drier and spicier. If you are unsure where to start, our guide to bourbon vs. rye in cocktails walks through it.

Mind the temperature

An Old Fashioned has ice in the glass to keep it cold. A Manhattan does not, so the glass has to do that work. Chill it first, and do not pour a Manhattan you plan to nurse for an hour.

Treat the garnish as an ingredient

The orange oil on an Old Fashioned and the cherry in a Manhattan both change how the drink smells and finishes. Use a fresh peel and a decent cherry, and skip the fruit salad.

Which One to Make Tonight

If you want to taste the whiskey with the edges taken off, make an Old Fashioned. If you want something richer and more aromatic, make a Manhattan. Most people who like one end up keeping both in rotation. The Old Fashioned side is ready now in the Old Fashioned syrup collection, and the Manhattan syrup is open for pre-order and ships early December.

Link to share

Use this link to share the article with a friend.