Few cocktails capture the spirit of whiskey quite like the Manhattan. This classic drink balances bold flavors with smooth sophistication, making it a favorite for both casual sippers and seasoned enthusiasts. If you want to craft a flawless Manhattan at home, the right ingredients and techniques make all the difference.
Choosing The Right Ingredients For Your Manhattan
The foundation of any great Manhattan is quality whiskey paired with complementary flavors. Selecting the right components ensures a cocktail that’s balanced, flavorful, and easy to enjoy.
Pick Your Whiskey
Traditionally, rye whiskey is the go-to choice for a Manhattan. Its spicy notes add complexity and cut through the sweetness of the other ingredients. Bourbon works well too, offering a richer, smoother profile with hints of vanilla and caramel. Whichever you choose, opt for a whiskey you enjoy sipping neat, as it’s the star of the show. Consider experimenting with different brands and age statements; a well-aged rye can bring out deeper flavors that might surprise you. Some enthusiasts even explore lesser-known whiskeys, such as wheat or blended varieties, to create unique twists on the classic recipe.
Use Proof Syrup Manhattan Cocktail Syrup
Instead of juggling bitters, sugar, and vermouth, try a pre-mixed Manhattan syrup like Proof Syrup’s Manhattan flavor. It combines bitters and vermouth flavors perfectly balanced for this cocktail. This syrup simplifies the process without sacrificing authenticity, making it ideal for home mixologists who want consistent results quickly. Using a syrup allows precise control over sweetness and bitterness, ensuring each cocktail is tailored to your taste. For those who enjoy a bit of experimentation, consider adding a splash of flavored bitters or even a hint of herbal liqueur to elevate the drink further.
Don’t Forget The Garnish
A classic Manhattan is traditionally garnished with a maraschino cherry or an orange twist. The cherry adds a subtle sweetness, while the orange peel introduces a bright citrus aroma. Both elevate the drinking experience and add a touch of elegance. For a more adventurous garnish, try using a Luxardo cherry, which is richer and more complex than the standard maraschino. A sprig of fresh thyme or rosemary can introduce an aromatic element that complements the whiskey beautifully. Remember, the garnish is not just for decoration; it plays a crucial role in your cocktail's overall flavor profile, enhancing the sensory experience with each sip.

Step-By-Step Guide To Making The Perfect Manhattan
Crafting a Manhattan is straightforward, but attention to detail will elevate your drink from good to exceptional. Follow these steps for a smooth, balanced cocktail.
Ingredients You’ll Need
- 2 ounces rye or bourbon whiskey
- 1 ounce Proof Syrup Manhattan cocktail syrup
- Ice cubes
- Maraschino cherry or orange peel for garnish
Mixing Instructions
- Fill a mixing glass with ice cubes to chill.
- Add the whiskey and Proof Syrup Manhattan syrup.
- Stir gently for about 20 seconds until well chilled.
- Strain the mixture into a chilled coupe or martini glass.
- Garnish with a maraschino cherry or an orange peel twist.
Tips For Best Results
- Use fresh, high-quality ice to avoid dilution.
- Stir, not shake, to keep the cocktail clear and silky.
- Chill your glass beforehand for a cooler, more refreshing sip.
The choice of whiskey can significantly influence the flavor profile of your Manhattan. Rye whiskey tends to impart a spicier, more robust character, while bourbon offers a smoother, sweeter taste. Experimenting with different brands can lead to delightful discoveries, as each distillery has its unique notes and complexities. Consider trying a small-batch or craft whiskey to add a personal touch to your cocktail, as these often have distinct flavor profiles that can enhance your drink.
Another aspect to consider is the type of bitters you use. While traditional Angostura bitters are a classic choice, there are many artisanal bitters available that can add an exciting twist to your Manhattan. Flavors like orange, chocolate, or aromatic bitters can complement the whiskey and syrup beautifully, creating a cocktail that is uniquely yours. Don't hesitate to experiment with different combinations until you find the perfect balance that suits your palate.
Why Use Proof Syrup For Your Manhattan?
Proof Syrup started in a cocktail bar in Decatur, Georgia, with the goal of simplifying classic cocktails without losing their essence. Their Manhattan syrup is crafted to deliver the perfect balance of bitters and vermouth flavors, so you don’t need to measure multiple ingredients. This innovation allows both novice and experienced mixologists to enjoy the rich, complex taste of a Manhattan without the hassle of traditional preparation methods.
Convenience Meets Quality
Proof Syrup’s Manhattan syrup is hand-mixed in small batches using natural ingredients, without preservatives. This means you get fresh, authentic flavor every time. It’s vegan and gluten-free, making it accessible to many dietary preferences. The commitment to quality is evident in every bottle, as the creators source their ingredients from trusted suppliers who share their passion for excellence. This attention to detail ensures that each sip of your Manhattan is not only delicious but also reflects the craftsmanship that goes into making the syrup.
Consistent Flavor Every Time
Mixing cocktails at home can sometimes lead to inconsistent results. Using a pre-balanced syrup removes guesswork, so your Manhattans taste just right with every pour. It’s a quick way to impress guests or enjoy a quality drink after a long day. The syrup's formulation captures the essence of a classic Manhattan, combining the rich notes of rye whiskey with the sweetness of vermouth and the aromatic complexity of bitters. This means you can recreate the ambiance of a high-end cocktail bar in the comfort of your own home, making it perfect for gatherings or a cozy night in.
Versatility Beyond the Classic
While the Manhattan is a staple cocktail, Proof Syrup’s versatility allows you to experiment with other drinks as well. You can use the syrup as a base for creative twists on classic cocktails or even incorporate it into dessert recipes for a unique flavor profile. Imagine a Manhattan-flavored ice cream or a cocktail-infused cake that brings the sophistication of your favorite drink to the dessert table. This opens up a world of possibilities for entertaining and culinary exploration, making Proof Syrup a must-have in any home bar.
Experimenting With Your Manhattan
Once you master the classic Manhattan, there’s room to explore variations that suit your taste or the season.
Try Different Whiskey Types
Swap rye for bourbon or even a smoky Scotch to create new flavor profiles. Each whiskey brings its own character, from spicy to sweet to peaty.
Add Seasonal Twists
In cooler months, adding a dash of Proof Syrup’s Pumpkin Spice or Black Walnut syrups can add warmth and depth. For a lighter touch, a splash of citrus or a different garnish can refresh the drink.
Batch Cocktails For Entertaining
Proof Syrup’s consistent flavors make it easy to scale up recipes for parties. Mix a large batch of Manhattans in advance, chill, and serve with minimal fuss.

Storing And Serving Your Manhattan Ingredients
Proper storage keeps your syrups and spirits fresh, ensuring every cocktail tastes its best.
Store Syrups Correctly
Proof Syrup recommends refrigerating opened bottles and shaking well before use. Most syrups have shelf lives ranging from 3 months to 2 years, depending on the flavor, so check expiration dates to maintain freshness.
Keep Whiskey At Optimal Temperature
Whiskey is best served slightly chilled or at room temperature, depending on preference. Avoid storing whiskey in the freezer, as it can dull the flavors.
Elevate Your Home Cocktail Game
Making a Manhattan at home doesn’t have to be complicated. With quality ingredients, Proof Syrup’s Manhattan cocktail syrup, and a good whiskey, you can enjoy bar-quality drinks with minimal effort. Whether you’re winding down after work or hosting friends, this recipe delivers smooth, balanced flavor every time.
Ready to try? Explore Proof Syrup’s range of cocktail syrups and find your perfect match for easy, delicious cocktails.
Get Your Proof Syrup Today
Ready to elevate your cocktail experience with the Perfect Manhattan? Look no further than Proof Syrup to bring the art of the craft cocktail into your home. Our all-natural cocktail syrups are designed for whiskey lovers like you, who appreciate the ease of creating bar-quality drinks. With Proof Syrup, you're just a pour away from the perfect cocktail. Shop Now and start impressing your guests with your mixology skills!